Last year for Christmas we gave them a little standing flip book with a thought for each week of the year.
Beaded bookmarks with "Be an Example" theme charm to encourage them to read their scriptures 5 minutes a day. You could do them with next year's theme.
We recently had Elaine S. Dalton, General Young Women President, come speak at a fireside and we had encouraged all the girls to have the new Virtue value in their Personal Progress done. To celebrate those who did, and encourage those others to keep working we gave them a gold virtue charm to add to their bookmarks.
For Christmas this year, we are giving them the word "Courage" in vinyl lettering to put on their mirrors and remind them of this years theme.
For birthdays next year, we are giving fun colorful socks with a thought about walking in the footsteps of Christ. (edit: see the saying and actual socks we used here)
I hope these ideas help! Also, please feel free to share ideas you have in the comments!
P.S. Don't forget to sign up for free Tipsy updates via RSS or email.