Here is a small gift religious gift idea. This was for my YW adviser's birthday. I started with a small clay lamp. Then, I wrote a note about how she is an example of someone who keeps their lamp full and helps us keep ours full. You could say "an example of the believers" since it is the mutual theme this year. I rolled it up like a scroll, tied it with some raffia, and put it in the hole in the top of the lamp.
Then, I made a ribbon from scrapbook paper by cutting thin strips, curling them with scissors and stapling them together. I also cut a bunch of strips and squished them up to look like Easter grass to put in the bottom of the bag. I made a matching tag, and tied it and the scrap bow to the clear treat bag with raffia. I think it turned out pretty cute.